|
İÇİNDEKİLER
TABLE OF CONTENT
ABSTRACT 5
AKNOWLEDGEMENTS 7
DEDICATION 9
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS 11
TABLE OF CONTENT 13
CHAPTER 1:
INTRODUCTİON
I. Research Background 19
II. Research aims and questions 29
III. Research Methodologies 29
IV. Outline and Structure of Thesis 32
CHAPTER 2:
CHARACTERİSTİCS OF THE CONSUMERONLİNE CONSUMER – IN LAW AND POLİCY
I. Introduction 33
II. The Importance of Consumer Protection 33
A. Historical Evolution of the European Union Consumer Policy 33
B. Justification of Consumer Protection 43
III. The Notion of Consumer 48
A. The General Definition of Consumer 48
B. Who is Considered a Consumer? 50
C. Non–Legal Definition of Consumer 51
D. Legal Definition of Consumer 53
1. The European Union 54
2. The United Kingdom 57
3. Türkiye 59
IV. Vulnerability of Consumer 61
V. Concept of Online Consumer 66
A. Who is the Online Consumer? 66
1. What is E–commerce? 67
a) The Definition of E–commerce 68
b) Different Types of E–commerce 69
c) Understanding the Benefit of E–commerce to Consumers 72
B. The Nature of Online Consumer 73
C. Economic Impact of Online Consumers in the European Union, United
Kingdom, and Türkiye 76
D. The Current Issues to Online Consumer 79
VI. Conclusion 81
CHAPTER 3:
ONLİNE DİSPUTE RESOLUTİON FOR CROSS–BORDER CONSUMER DİSPUTES: ONLİNE ARBİTRATİON
I. Introduction 83
II. Dispute Resolution Mechanism 84
A. Litigation 84
1. Challenges of Traditional Dispute Resolution 86
B. Alternative Dispute Resolution 89
1. Negotiation 92
2. Mediation 94
3. Arbitration 98
a) Characteristics of Arbitration 98
i) Arbitrator as an Impartial Third Party 98
ii) Confidentiality 100
iii) Finality of Award 101
iv) Enforceability of Award 103
b) Compared Mediation with Arbitration 104
C. Online Dispute Resolution 107
1. The Current State of Türkiye’s ODR Platform 111
a) Consumer Arbitration Committees 111
2. EU ODR Platform 114
a) Functionating of the EU ODR platform 114
b) An Analysis of the EU ODR Platform 116
i) Inadequacy in Conformity to ODR Regulation Conditions 116
ii) Limitation of the Platform Regarding Dealing with
Fragmentation and how it Affects Consumers 118
iii) Low Participation of Businesses on the ODR Platform 120
iv) Lack of Enforcement Mechanism 122
III. Online Arbitration for Cross–Border Dispute 126
A. Definition and Mechanism of Online Arbitration for Cross– Border D
isputes 126
B. Benefits of Online Arbitration for Cross–Border Disputes 128
1. Accessibility and Convenience 128
2. Cost–effectiveness 128
3. Time Efficiency 131
IV. The Interaction between Digital Technology and Arbitration 134
A. How can Digital Technology be Employed in Arbitration? 134
1. Online case management systems 135
2. Video conferencing 136
V. The function of online arbitration 138
A. The existence and validity of online arbitration agreement 138
B. Appointment of online arbitrator 143
C. The Legal Significance of the Place of Online Arbitration 150
D. The Complexity of Applicable Law in Online Arbitration 153
E. The commencement of online arbitrator process 157
F. The issuance of an online arbitral award 161
VI. Challenges of Online Arbitration 164
A. Practical Challenges in Online Arbitration: Cybersecurity, Privacy and
Confidentiality 164
1. Cybersecurity 165
2. Privacy 168
3. Confidentiality 170
B. Legal Challenges in Online Arbitration: Due Process, the Validity of Online
Arbitration Agreement and Arbitrability of an Online Consumer Dispute 173
1. Due process 173
2. The Validity of Online Arbitration Agreement 181
3. Arbitrability of Online Consumer Dispute 184
VII. Conclusion 186
CHAPTER 4:
ARBİTRABİLİTY OF SUBJECT–MATTER UNDER INTERNATİONAL AND NATİONAL LAW: CONSUMER DİSPUTE
I. Introduction 189
II. General Principle of Arbitrability 190
A. Objective and Subjective Arbitrability 193
1. Objective Arbitrability 193
2. Subjective Arbitrability 197
III. Arbitrability as a Condition for the Validity of an Arbitration
Agreementment for the Jurisdiction of the
Arbitral Tribunal 200
IV. Who Should Decide on Subject–Matter Arbitrability? The Principle of
Separability and the Principle of Competence and Competence 201
A. The Principle of Separability 201
B. The Principle of Competence–Competence 205
V. Subject–matter Arbitrability under the International and
National Laws 208
A. Arbitrability under International Law 208
1. Arbitrability under the New York Convention 208
2. Arbitrability under the UNCITRAL Model Law 214
3. Uniform international legislation on arbitrability 218
B. National legislations to Subject–matter Arbitrability: Türkiye, Germany,
England, and France's law 221
1. Türkiye’s Approaches to Arbitrability 221
2. Germany’s Approaches to Arbitrability 227
3. France's Approaches to Arbitrability 233
4. England and Wales Approaches to Arbitrability 237
5. Uniform national law on arbitrability 241
VI. Conclusion 242
CHAPTER 5:
ARE BUSİNESS–TO–CONSUMER ARBİTRATİON CLAUSES VALİD UNDER THE EU, ENGLAND AND WALES, AND TÜRKİYE LEGAL FRAMEWORK?
I. Introduction: 245
II. The effect of EU Regulation on Arbitration Agreements in
Consumer Contracts 247
A. Unfair Term Directive 93/13 as Substantive Law on the Consumer
Arbitration Agreement 249
1. Consumer Contracts 252
a) Consumer capacity in the form of unique protection in EU
Consumer arbitrations 252
2. Protection of the Weaker Party to the Online Standard Consumer
Contract: Substantive Justice 258
a) Substantive validity ment to the online arbitration
agreement 258
i) Online arbitration clause in standard contracts 264
A) Validity of consumer arbitration clauses in the browse–
wrap agreement 268
B) Validity of consumer arbitration clauses in Clickwrap
agreement 276
3. Essential Elements of Consumer Arbitration Clause Agreement:
Imbalance Power and Good– Faith 279
a) The Uniqueness of Consumer Arbitration Clause Agreement:
Bargaining Power 279
i) Potential cause of the lack of bargain power 280
A) Unequal information 281
B) Standardised terms 282
C) Cost of arbitration 284
D) Limited Options 287
E) Unequal Negotiation Power 288
ii) Solution to challenges 292
A) Enhancing consumer awareness 292
B) Cost Control and Legal Assistance 294
C) Model arbitration clauses 299
iii) Does Freedom of Contract naturalise the imbalance powered
between B2C in the EU? 316
b) The Interaction between Good Faith, and Consumer
Arbitration 318
i) Overview of Good Faith Principle in the Contracts 318
ii) Good Faith in Consumer Arbitration Agreements 320
VI. Validity of Online Arbitration Clause under the Turkish Laws 325
A. Overview 325
B. The issue of the online consumer arbitration clause 329
VII. Conclusion 334
CHAPTER 6:
TRANSPARENCY OF CONSUMER ARBİTRATİON CLAUSE İN THE ONLİNE BUSİNESS–TO–CONSUMER CONTRACTS.
I. Introduction 337
II. The Law Applicable to Online Arbitration Clauses 339
A. The Law on Consent to Arbitrate 339
B. Consent Based on Subjective vs Objective Standard 342
C. EU Laws Applicable to Online Arbitration Clauses 343
III. Transparency ments in Online Arbitration Clauses 347
A. Clear and Comprehensible Language 347
B. Prominent Display and Accessibility of Terms 349
C. Clear and Informed Consent 352
D. The Right to WithdrawOpt Out 355
IV. Challenges and Best Practices in Ensuring Transparency 357
A. Clickwrap vs. Browsewrap Contracts 357
B. Balancing Business Interests and Consumer Protection 360
C. Integrating EU ments into Website Design and Contract Formation 363
D. The Role of Alternative Dispute Resolution and Consumer Arbitration 366
V. Case Studies and Jurisprudence on Transparency of Online
Arbitration Clause 369
A. European Court of Justice Cases on Transparency of Contractual Terms 369
B. Lessons and Best Practices for Online Arbitration Clause in the Industry 373
1. Uber Case on Online Arbitration Clause 374
a) Meyer v. Uber Technologies Case 374
b) Cullinane v. Uber Technologies Case: 376
VI. AI in Search of Unfair Arbitration Clauses in Online
Consumer Contracts 378
VII. Conclusion 381
CHAPTER 7:
CONCLUSİON – ANALYSİS AND DİSCUSSİON – DRAWİNG OUT SOLUTİONS
AND POTENTİAL PATHWAYS TO THE FUTURE OF CONSUMER ARBİTRATİON.
I. Introduction 383
II. Analysis and Discussion 385
A. The Legal Capacity of the Consumer 389
B. Applicable Law and Rule 390
C. Procedural Fairness 391
III. Drawing out Solutions and Potential Pathways to the Future of
Consumer Arbitration 393
A. Uniform Regulation 395
1. Uniform Rules on the Arbitrability of Online Consumer Disputes 397
2. Create a Consensus on the Legality of Online Arbitration Agreements 399
B. Enhance Online Arbitration’s Procedural Fairness 401
IV. Future Recommendations 404
V. Conclusion 404
BIBLIOGRAPHY 407 |