|
İÇİNDEKİLER
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PREFACE 7
ABSTRACT 9
TABLE OF CONTENTS 11
LIST OF TABLES 15
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
I. THE CENTRAL TENSION: INVESTOR PROTECTION AND STATE
REGULATORY AUTONOMY 17
II. ENERGY INVESTMENT LAW AND THE ISSUES 18
III. THE TRIANGULAR LEGAL FRAMEWORK OF INTERNATONAL ENERGY
INVESTMENT 24
IV. PSEG GLOBAL INC. V REPUBLIC OF TURKEY: A CASE STUDY OF
REGULATORY CHANGE AND INVESTOR PROTECTION 25
V. SETTING THE CONTEXT FOR ANALYSIS: ENERGY INVESTMENT SCENARIO 29
VI. THE ARGUMENT AND STRUCTURE OF THE BOOK 32
CHAPTER II
NATIONAL ENERGY REGULATION AND THE
INVESTMENT FRAMEWORK
I. INTRODUCTION 35
II. THE EVOLVING ROLE OF STATES IN THE ENERGY SECTOR 37
III. DOMESTIC LAW AS THE FIRST LAYER OF THE INVESTMENT
FRAMEWORK 39
IV. TOWARD A COHERENT NATIONAL LEGAL FRAMEWORK 40
V. REGULATORY RISK AND LIMITS OF STATE COMMITMENTS 42
A. The Problem of Over–Promising 42
B. Transparency, Accountability and Administrative Governance 46
VI. CONCLUSION 48
12 Table of Contents
CHAPTER III
ENERGY INVESTMENT DISPUTES: RECURRING PATTERNS AND
REGULATORY CONFLICTS
I. INTRODUCTION 51
II. METHODOLOGICAL APPROACH AND SCOPE OF THE CASE–LAW REVIEW 53
III. SUMMARY TABLES 53
IV. OUTCOMES 60
A. Nationalities of Respondent States and Home States of Claimants 60
B. Main Reasons for Claims 61
C. Applicable Investment Treaties Underpinning the Cases 61
D. Arbitral Rules 62
E. Amounts Claimed 62
F. Key Measures Foreign Investors Challenged 64
1. Fair and Equitable Treatment 64
2. Direct and Indirect Expropriation 65
a. Defining Indirect Expropriation 66
b. Substantial Deprivation of Value of Investment – “Effects–
Based Approach” 69
c. Termination of Long–Term Agreements 71
V. CONCLUSION 72
CHAPTER IV
BALANCING PUBLIC INTEREST AND INVESTOR PROTECTION
UNDER INTERNATIONAL INVESTMENT AGREEMENTS
I. INTRODUCTION 73
II. INTERNATIONAL INVESTMENT TREATIES: STRUCTURE, EVOLUTION,
AND REGULATORY SPACE 74
III. CASE STUDIES 79
A. Charanne B.V. & Construction Investments S.A.R.L. v. Spain 80
B. Eiser Infrastructure Ltd and Energia Solar Luxemburg S.A.R.I v Spain 82
1. Outcome of the Cases 84
IV. SIGNIFICANCE FOR THE DRAFTING OF INVESTMENT TREATIES 85
V. KEY PROVISIONS OF INVESTMENT TREATIES IN THE ENERGY SECTOR:
TOWARDS A MORE BALANCED TREATY FRAMEWORK 86
A. Fair and Equitable Treatment 86
1. Drafting the Fair and Equitable Treatment Standard 90
Table of Contents 13
B. Expropriation – “Taking” 95
1. The Evolution of the Expropriation Provisions in Investment
Treaties 101
C. Dispute Settlement Provisions – “The Need for a Neutral Process” 103
1. Evolution of ISDS Provisions in Investment Treaties 105
2. Popularity of Arbitration in the Energy Sector 108
3. Drafting Dispute Settlement Provisions in the Energy Investment 109
4. Popularity of the ICSID 110
VI. CONCLUSION 112
CHAPTER V
BALANCING STATE SOVEREIGNTY AND
INVESTOR INTERESTS UNDER ENERGY INVESTMENT CONTRACTS
I. INTRODUCTION 115
II. AN OVERVIEW OF ENERGY INVESTMENT CONTRACTS 117
A. The Legal Nature of Energy Contracts 119
III. KEY PROVISIONS OF ENERGY INVESTMENT CONTRACTS 122
A. Stabilization Clauses 122
1. Main Legal Issues with the Stabilization Clauses 124
a. Necessity of Stabilization Clauses – Are They a Sine Qua Non
Tool? 124
b. Validity of Stabilization Clauses 126
c. Inconsistency with Domestic Laws 128
2. Drafting Stabilization Clauses 132
B. Dispute Resolution Clauses 132
1. Main Issues with Dispute Settlement Clauses in the Investment
Contracts 133
IV. CONCLUSION 139
CHAPTER VI
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
BIBLIOGRAPHY 151
I. PRIMARY MATERIALS 151
A. Official Documents 151
14 Table of Contents
1. Legislations and Treaties 151
2. Cases and Arbitral Awards 152
3. Contracts 157
II. SECONDARY MATERIALS 157
1. Books 157
2. Chapters in Books 160
3. Journals and Law Review Articles, Research/Working Papers,
Seminars/Conference Notes and Newspaper Articles 165
4. Reports / Outlooks 176
5. Online Sources / Internet Websites 178 |